You should have 4 buttons (from left to right) - Ban Now (Red), Give Warning (Yellow), Un-Ban/reset warnings (Green), Report Post (Blue) once a post is reported the Blue button turns orangey.. click the orangey button and it clears the report (turns the button blue again) and also locks the report post.
Also just been to your site, you may aswell make everything 'Private [Hidden]' because now when you click on a forum it asks you to login.
It's not the years honey, it's the mileage...
I do not provide any install services for phpBB, Mods or Styles.
Please do not pm me for support/scripting help - you won't get any reply. If you have a question then make a post in the appropriate forum.